Streetwise Professor

December 1, 2008


Filed under: Commodities,Economics,Energy,Politics,Russia — The Professor @ 9:45 pm

Like a spoiled child who has lost a game at his birthday party, Vladimir Putin cries: “It’s NOT FAIR!“:

Prime Minister Vladimir Putin described the effect foreign markets have on domestic share prices as “unfair” during a government meeting Monday, saying the values of the securities do not accurately reflect those of the companies themselves.

Putin also spoke out against insider trading and again blamed the West for the country’s economic difficulties, adding that those trading on domestic exchanges would be compensated for financial losses, Interfax reported.

“Decisions concerning which securities to buy or sell on Russian markets are, for the most part, made abroad,” Putin said, the news agency reported. “Moreover, the criteria by which these decisions are made have very little connection to the actual state of our economy or Russian companies.”

At the same time, he was careful to point out that the country did not want to exclude foreign investors.

“No one is preparing to limit the activities of foreign capital in the Russian stock market — we welcome foreign investors,” Putin said. “But at the same time, the task lies in properly building a large class of domestic investors as a powerful and capable financial institution of its own.”

While the lack of domestic investors is clearly a problem and shares in Russian companies trade at levels below what might be expected given their fundamentals, said James Beadle, director of Pilgrim Asset Management, the blame for their performance should be shared around.

“On the face of it, Putin is completely correct — I think a lot of the market’s reaction has had nothing to do with the Russian economy,” Beadle said. “But Russia’s situation has been, as we know, worse than most emerging markets. I put that down to the weak economic environment, the political risk and a lack of domestic investors.”

While lashing out at the West, Putin said the government remained committed to turning Moscow into an international financial center.

“In the very near future, the government will examine a comprehensive plan regarding the financial center’s creation,” he said, adding that the financial crisis would perhaps change the global economic pecking order, affording Russia greater opportunity to achieve its goal.

Vladimir Milovidov, head of the Federal Financial Markets Service, followed Putin’s comments at the meeting by elaborating on the state’s plans for compensating investors for market losses, Interfax reported.

Milovidov explained that this would be achieved through a mechanism based on the Deposit Insurance Agency, which is designed to insure individual bank deposits.

“I don’t see any clear obstacles to the creation of such a system of compensation based on the idea of the Deposit Insurance Agency,” Milovidov said, although he added that the question would require further consultation with various ministries and departments.

There was skepticism over whether such a plan could work.

“It seems a little unrealistic to me,” said Tom Mundy, an analyst at Renaissance Capital. “Maybe it would be better to think about how Russia can restructure its financial institutions.”

While saying there was some truth to the charges Putin made, Mundy also said not all of the blame for weak domestic markets should be placed elsewhere.

“Russia’s financial institution did break down. The banks didn’t lend,” he said. “[The crisis] is an inherited problem, and I can understand why the market is frustrated. But it does not mean that Russia is completely blameless.

“There is a little bit of blame to be passed overseas, and there is some internal blame as well with these oligarchs who had [overleveraged their companies],” said Ronald Smith, chief strategist at Alfa Bank. “There’s blame all the way around.”

In line with Putin’s comments, the Presidium approved a strategic development project for Russia’s financial markets through 2020, Milovidov reported. He added that the Presidium also approved a draft law designed to combat insider trading.

Mundy said the Kremlin’s focus on a global financial center pointed to a healthy desire for economic integration and that, in the end, the crisis might actually help push along Russia’s economic development.

“‘The next stage in Russia’s development is probably creating more transparency,” he said.

I especially like the part about insider trading.   I’m sure no silovik ever does that.

The prattle about Russia as a financial center is simply delusional.   No secure property rights, no credible policy commitments, no rule of law, corporate raiding, expropriation of foreign investors–yeah, that’s the foundation for a world financial center.   You betcha!

And what’s the deal about compensating those trading on domestic exchanges for their losses?   That’s the ticket, give investors a put paid for with government money.   No better way to encourage wild risk taking–private gains, socialized losses.   The proposal also smacks of a scheme to tunnel state assets and direct them to the pockets of political favorites.   We are repeatedly told that individual investors don’t play the Russian stock market–that it is the playground of a limited set of connected players, the oligarchs prominent among them.   So this seems like just another bailout.

Tom Mundy gets a nomination for the Understatement of the Year Award:

“It seems a little unrealistic to me,” said Tom Mundy, an analyst at Renaissance Capital. “Maybe it would be better to think about how Russia can restructure its financial institutions.”

Ya think?

Print Friendly, PDF & Email


  1. The executives at Mechel must have gotten a bit of satisfaction from this article. I wonder which doctor Putin will go see to heal the Russian economy 😉

    Comment by Michel — December 1, 2008 @ 10:05 pm

  2. Yeah, but cold comfort to the Mechel folks, I’m sure. Dr. Kevorkian comes to mind.

    The ProfessorComment by The Professor — December 1, 2008 @ 10:20 pm

  3. Bullies are always the first to whine about the unfairness of it all when they can no longer command all around them to do as they please.

    Comment by Michel — December 1, 2008 @ 10:35 pm

  4. What a crowd of economically challenged clowns, but, what do you expect from St. Petersburg FSB cronies trying to run a modern economy. It’s always plans and promises in Russia. It’s no wonder that the numbed citizenry prefer to be disengaged and living with a permanent bunker mentality.

    Here’s an interesting site I stumbled upon, modeled after the free Svetlana Bakhima site( The numbers have doubled in the week that I’ve checked back and the comments reveal utter disgust with Putin:

    As small as the numbers are so far, it is gratifying to see a few brave voices come forward at a spontaneous internet site. I say brave because they have every reason to expect that their names and IPS addresses are being recorded.

    Comment by penny — December 2, 2008 @ 12:59 pm

  5. Again, the irony here is breathtaking.

    Russia’s are almost pathologically consumed with desire for “prestige” in they eyes
    of other countries, and yet they choose a man who has scholars refering to him as a
    spoiled child.

    They, of course, remain clueless about this because that same man has liquidated their

    And so it goes in Russia. And so it goes.

    Comment by La Russophobe — December 4, 2008 @ 3:53 pm

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a comment

Powered by WordPress