Streetwise Professor

July 31, 2010

What *Isn’t* Vulnerable to Corruption?

Filed under: Economics,Politics,Russia — The Professor @ 7:36 pm

This article from The Moscow Times, about Moscow’s problem with stray dogs, had me chuckling.  It provides an interesting perspective on how pervasive corruption is in the country.  I mean, in Russia, the connected can even find a way to make a buck–or a million bucks–from Fido:

By the numbers, the authorities care about stray dogs as much as people.

Moscow City Hall has allocated $190 per month for every stray dog that is housed in its animal shelters this year — the same amount that Prime Minister Vladimir Putin has deemed as Russia’s minimum living wage in 2010.

In addition, millions of dollars have been earmarked to construct animal shelters and to neuter strays.

But despite the cash windfall, few shelters are opening, and there has been no decrease in the 30,000 stray dogs that City Hall and animal rights activists say are roaming the streets.

Mayor Yury Luzhkov says the problem has grown so acute that hundreds of strays might need to be put to sleep.

“In good facilities, a dog can live up to 15 years,” Luzhkov said on city-controlled TV Center television last month. “We cannot take care of dogs for such a long period of time. No city budget could survive such a heavy burden.”

But animal rights activists and a former City Duma deputy say the real burden on the city budget is that money earmarked for the animals has disappeared into a black hole.

Indeed, a review of official documents obtained by The Moscow Times found that stray dogs are part of a lucrative — and extremely murky — business that has helped enrich a relative of at least one senior city official. The review also suggests that poor planning and a lack of due diligence are costing the city dearly.

If there’s a will to chisel dough–and believe me, there’s a will–there’s a way.  Or a million ways.

The story also reminds me of my rather humorous encounter with Moscow’s strays, in August 2005.  I was walking through Red Square on my way back to the Hotel Rossia–hey, if I was going to do Moscow, I was going to do it old school–near midnight one evening.  I was with two Italians, now American academics, one male, and one female.*  While we were walking through the ???????, about 10 of the skinniest dogs I’ve ever seen came loping along, their tongues hanging out in the warm evening.  (It wasn’t as hot as it is now in Moscow, or even close, but it was uncomfortably warm.  And the Hotel Rossia didn’t have AC.  Man did they improve the country by blowing up that dump.)

No big deal, right?  The dogs looked pretty harmless.  And one boy dog was very interested in one girl dog so not so interested in three things on two legs.  But the female Italian screamed “I’m terrified of dogs!” and jumped into my arms, wailing hysterically.  The male Italian, I kid you not, was hiding behind me. I just yelled “scat” a few times and stomped my foot heavily (my arms being tied up by one panicked Italian), and the dogs just gave me a look and turned 90 degrees, loping off towards St. Basil’s.

Little did I know that there was gold in them there paws.

* I will think twice before going around Moscow with Italian academics again.  The three of us had broken off from a larger party after dinner.  The others–all Italian–were arguing with the maitre d’ of the restaurant where we’d eaten.  The place gave all the indications of being mob friendly (you’d think Italians would notice!), and I had no interest in doing a reprise of the Uneasy Rider: the last thing I wanted was to get in a fight, in Moscow Russia on a Saturday night.  So I threw money on the table and split.  I seriously checked the internet the next few mornings to see whether there any reports of missing Italians.  Apparently they made it back alive.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email


  1. […] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Craig pirrong, Craig pirrong. Craig pirrong said: Updated my SWP blog post: What *Isn't* Vulnerable to Corruption? ( ) […]

    Pingback by Tweets that mention Streetwise Professor » What *Isn’t* Vulnerable to Corruption? -- — July 31, 2010 @ 7:59 pm

  2. Have the Russians considered selling all their stray dogs to, say, Korea?

    Comment by Ostap Bender — August 1, 2010 @ 7:38 am

  3. The more important aspect of this story is that the amount budgeted by the city of Moscow for the care of STRAY DOGS is exactly the same as the amount budgeted by the Kremlin for MINIMUM WAGE PAYMENTS TO PEOPLE.

    That tells you all you need to know about how much the Putin regime cares about the people who live in Russia. With a GDP only double that of Russia, France pays TEN TIMES more as miniumum wage. Only a handful of countries ON THE PLANET are stingier than Russia when allocating minimum wage as compared to per capita GDP.

    In Russia, in other words, you might as well be a dog.

    Comment by La Russophobe — August 1, 2010 @ 8:38 am

  4. Have the Russians considered selling all their stray dogs to, say, Korea?

    No, but the governor of the Astrakhan region is thinking to sell locusts to China. Yes, seriously.

    Comment by peter — August 1, 2010 @ 1:54 pm

  5. Man did they improve the country by blowing up that dump.)

    Heresy! Heresy! Once they’d blown that place up it was impossible to get city centre accommodation for less than $200 per night (and that at the apalling Belgrad hotel). The Rossiya at least had the advantage of being “cheap” by Moscow standards ($90-$100) per night and the 1,000 rooms at least meant the place was never full.

    Comment by Tim Newman — August 8, 2010 @ 10:22 pm

  6. @Tim. LOL. I guess . . . . I still wonder if the price differential compensated for the decided lack of amenities. Would have been interesting to run a hedonic regression 🙂

    The place was indeed effing immense. I remember the walk from my room to the business center–it seemed like miles.

    I was there in the summer, and almost suffocated to death. I had two choices: keep the windows shut and toss and turn in the heat, or keep them open, and toss and turn from the traffic noise rising from the embankment.

    I shudder at the thought of the Belgrad, if it is “appalling” by comparison to the HR.

    I was curious whether the surveillance system installed when the place was built for a Party conference in the ’60s (i.e., bugs in every room) was still in operation ’05 🙂

    The ProfessorComment by The Professor — August 9, 2010 @ 6:42 am

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a comment

Powered by WordPress